In the fast-changing world of video games, few franchises endure like Rockstar Games’ Grand Theft Auto. As excitement builds for Grand Theft Auto 6, industry analyst Mat Piscatella offers an interesting theory about its biggest competitor. He suggests that the toughest rival for the upcoming game isn’t a new title or a rival sequel; it’s the franchise’s own record-breaking game, Grand Theft Auto 5.
While this claim may seem surprising, it is backed by the remarkable longevity and popularity of GTA 5. Released in 2013, the game still ranks on global bestseller lists and remains one of the most-played titles on the market. This is an impressive achievement for a game that is almost 12 years old. Its lasting success highlights its appealing open world and high replayability, along with the steady updates for its online mode, Grand Theft Auto Online. The ongoing engagement of its large player base has made it a permanent part of the gaming community.
The argument gains strength from the historical failures of “GTA killers.” Many ambitious games, such as the troubled reboot of Saints Row and the lesser-known MindsEye, have tried and failed to challenge the franchise, eventually being forgotten. Even well-known series like Ubisoft’s Watch Dogs, which share similar design ideas, haven’t released a new game in years. This lack of credible competition emphasizes GTA 5’s unique role as a constant bestseller, creating an internal barrier for the successor.
As Rockstar prepares to release GTA 6 nearly 13 years after its last game, it faces a special challenge. The studio needs to create a game that attracts a new generation while also convincing a loyal community to shift away from a game they have enjoyed for over a decade. The strong momentum and cultural impact of Grand Theft Auto 5 might be the biggest obstacle for its successor. The new title must not only be good but also be an essential and transformative experience for its dedicated players.
